One just has to look at the huge discrepancy between critic reviews and audience scores to know that something is wrong.
So today, I am going to lay out what I liked about the movie, and what it got so very very wrong (from my perspective and those who I agree with).
Spoilers Ahead! (Obviously)
...
...
...
Still with me? Ok. Cool.
First, I'll handle what I liked.
The visuals were beautiful. Even the weirdest creature had enough substance to seem real enough. The (one) lightsaber fight scene was wonderfully choreographed and brutal (violence should be violence, for better or worse). The humor was abundant and enjoyable, if perhaps the most silly since Jar Jar came on screen in the Phantom Menace.
I'm just going to say it. The acting is probably some of, if not the, best that the series has seen. From Luke and Leia to new characters like Kylo Ben and Rose, the acting was spot on.
If visuals, action, and acting are all you really care about, then I can see how you would really enjoy The Last Jedi.
Now for the fun slog of what I disliked.
I feel that I should mention that I don't expect all movies to be high art. I don't expect most of them to be high brow in any fashion. At one point in my life I was watching too many videos from CinemaSins and getting down on all movies. It wasn't fun, and movies are supposed to be fun.
Thanks to the lovely videos of CinemaWins, I thankfully changed my criteria for a movie to look for the very simple answers to two questions: Did it make sense (by its universe's own rules)? Was I entertained?
The answer to the former was a definite NO. This is especially true if all you've ever seen of Star Wars are the movies. TV shows like Rebels and Clone Wars open the world up and add more force abilities (I've been told that Yoda once used the Force Projection power in an episode of Rebels).
I want to make sure that everyone gets that I'm not ragging on The Last Jedi because of nostalgia or one of my theories got blown up (because that's apparently an accusation that gets thrown around when one defends the movie?).
I'm ragging on The Last Jedi because, objectively, it is at best a mediocre movie, and more likely a bad one once you allow yourself to see past the surface shine.
Problem #1
The story wastes time and doesn't make a lick of sense. Or, it doesn't make sense within the scope of previous movies. This problem generally encompasses the other problems, but here's a few quick points.
45 minutes of film could have been cut out if Holdo had simply told Poe that "Yes, I do have a plan. I just need to you to trust me." instead of the whole "You're a dumb jock flyboy and we don't need your sort."
The Force Awakens basically said that the destruction of Starkiller Base disrupted/destroyed the First Order's military capabilities (and if they'd spend 30 years converting the planet into a superweapon, that's believable), and yet... Right at the start of the movie there's a whole damned fleet of star destroyers threatening the Rebel... Resistance because the First Order took the destruction of a massively expensive asset to take over the galaxy in the 5 hours since they destroyed the capital of the New Republic. Ugh.
Problem #2
The movie is entirely unfair or untrue to its characters.
I'm looking at you, Luke. But seriously, how do we go from the most hopeful and optimistic jedi warrior in the franchise to a cowardly middle aged man tempted to kill a boy because he "sensed the darkness growing in him."?
This was a man who forgave and believed in his father after the man blew up an entire planet, cut off his hand, tortured his sister, and killed who knows how many people.
And... we're supposed to believe that he almost killed a boy because he was suddenly afraid of "the darkness" inside of him. AND THEN instead of trying to fix the problem he created (which is supposedly something Jedi do and DEFINITELY something that the Real Luke would do) he runs away for 15-20 years to... fish and drink green milk and feel bad for himself.
This wasn't just not MY Luke. This character wasn't Luke. There's probably more to say, but why dwell?
Snoke was grossly underserved. Of all the new characters, I think this one smarts the most. Built up as a mysterious, knowledgeable, powerful replacement to Palpatine who is interested in obtaining Rey and wants to finish Kylo Ben's training in The Force Awakens... in The Last Jedi we get a figure who mocks Kylo for losing to a girl and wearing a mask. Who, as soon as he gets his fingers on Rey, immediately decides to torture her and order her death.
Then Kylo kills him and leaves us with no answers for this suddenly petulant character. That's just stupid.
Rey is still a Mary Sue. If Kylo is believed and her parents really were nobody, that she lived on Jakku her entire life until TFA... then she has no reason to be as good as she is at everything. The fighting and the piloting, hell, even the engineering aspects of her character are fairly believable with what we're given in her introduction. But if you're not trained in the force, no matter how powerful you are, the most you can expect is heightened reflexes and the odd precognitive flash. Actual force powers, even using a lightsaber without dismembering yourself, takes time, training and practice.
Time, training, and practice that Rey (apparently) hasn't had.
Unless Kylo is just blowing smoke. There's always that.
Finn and Rose do nothing. Their romance kind of just comes out of nowhere. This is a little nitpicky, but have you noticed how much Finn knows about everything First Order for having been a Janitor?
Also, they go for a "master codebreaker" and settle on DJ because... he's there.
My biggest complaint about Finn's non-arc is that the one moment they gave him, where he was facing his fears and might have made a difference... Rose took his sacrifice away from him and bye bye Rebel base. For all the people that the movie killed, losing Finn would have actually raised the stakes. But I guess killing the only black character would have been a little too daring for Disney.
Poe. Apparently Poe's character is off as well. Gonna be honest here. I'm not invested in Poe and I can barely remember him from the first movie. I guess he's a little more headstrong and reckless? Honestly, given how terrible of a leader Holdo was, I can commiserate with him trying to find a clear path forward.
Phasma is still being underserved, and for someone they keep trying to portray as a talented intimidating character, they sure to like to treat her as a punching bag. It's so bad that she's beaten in hand to hand by a frickin janitor. A janitor.
This one isn't a complaint. Kylo Ren not turning to the Light is great. Too bad he's still coming across as a petulant child rather than something to be feared.
Problem #3
Twists for the sake of twists. Finn is sacrificing himself! No he's not. Kylo is turning to the lightside! No he's not. Leia's dead! No she's not. Luke's here and he's facing Kylo! Oh, no he's not. And on and on and on.
"No, Luke. I am your father." Was a great twist. It was kind of foreshadowed, but it totally fit the story. What we got in Last Jedi was stupid twist after stupid twist that progressively lowered the stakes until there was no reason to care what happened because there was no reason to believe what we just saw would hold for more than a few seconds.
How can you remain invested in a movie when nothing it shows you turns out to be real? Hell, Snoke probably wasn't actually there to die. It was a life model decoy. They can do that now because Disney owns Marvel. Hell, JJ may make it so that Luke isn't actually dead either. The whole of The Last Jedi was just a dream...
Nitpicks!
Too many cutesy animals. You have the porgs (apparently they couldn't get rid of the puffins where they were filming so they made do. Forgivable enough, I suppose). The horse-cat things... Cute, but like that whole arc, pointless. And the crystal foxes. It's all just so... ugh. New and weird creatures are a part of Star Wars, but the vast majority of the time they should just... be a part of the world the characters are living in. Not showcased and making a pointlessly long movie even longer.
Finn really should have been allowed to sacrifice himself. None of the characters we "care" about were harmed or killed in any way and that just keeps the investment and the stakes low.
The force is broken now. One of the big points made in previous movies is that as powerful as the force is, those using it have limits. Anakin can't bring back the dead. Mace Windu (arguably second most powerful Jedi of his era behind Yoda) can't survive a 100 story drop after force electrocution. So why can Leia, with no meaningful training, suddenly survive in vaccuum? (Really, this nitpick could have been its own separate problem).
Hyperspace is a separate level of reality that ships travel through to circumvent the speed of light. Hyperspace is affected by heavy gravity from planets and stars but not much else. Suddenly it is a weapon to be used when the story calls for it. If Star Wars' FTL could be weaponized, surely we would have seen it before.
Who designed those God awful bombers? Y-Wings would have been WAY better and at this point in the story those are like, 80 year old designs. These bombers somehow have fewer defenses and move as slowly as a... I don't know, a crippled nonagenarian?
-And were those bombs pushed out by their racks or by gravity? If it was gravity, then Rian Johnson, like JJ Abrams, needs to brush up on his physics because that far from the planet's gravity well there isn't enough gravity to pull diddly to squat.
Did we really have to replay the beginning of Empire Strikes Back but with red salt and crappier rebel equipment? There's an entire galaxy for these directors and writers to explore and we keep getting the same beats. It's boring.
Summing it all up
The Last Jedi had so much potential to build on from the entire franchise. It could have taken us so may places. Instead it chose to play it (relatively) safe while trying to seem edgy. If Disney keeps playing fast and loose with this franchise then it will die. Not all at once, but each movie will start to make less money, and audiences will lose more interest because the thing that made Star Wars... Star Wars, isn't being put out there.
The last Jedi makes it seem like Rian Johnson has never seen any other Star Wars movie, and that's just a shame.
I hope JJ Abrams can turn the franchise back around with Episode IX, but I won't be seeing it opening weekend. Unless it's free. Can't really turn down free, can I?


.png)
